Michael and Jay are asked to serve jury duty together. Michael’s elected foreman and wants to move on the trial quickly so he can get home to watch the “Godfather” marathon on TV. But Jay won’t vote in guilty because she thinks there has to be a debate first. Thanks to that, Michael ends up missing the marathon, and has to rent the videos to catch up with the movie. At the video store, he meets an insurance salesman whom he mistakes for a mobster, and is convinced that the mob is after him due to the case. The case ends up being dismissed before they can vote, and Jay is disappointed that Michael wouldn’t back her up but has her revenge when Michael acts like a fool.